Is Omotic Afroasiatic? And other links.

I’ll add to this as I find resources for it. What reading I’ve done today suggests that Omotic predates agriculture, and that Cushitic split off from it during the Neolithic, as it has words for sheep/goat etc in it which arrive then. Quite interesting was a Blench book that pointed out North and South Omotic and Cushitic all have different roots for cattle, suggesting that pastoralism was foreign to them prior to the arrival of Asian neolithic domesticates, which doesn’t help the case for an early independant domestication of cattle in Africa. This also rather dents any claims to agriculture in the area prior to the split wth Cushitic, which dates to the arrival if ovicaprines (neolithic era, 7,500 bp or later).

I see Omotic clasified as Afro Asiatic, but there does seem to be a fair bit of dispute over this, with a couple of scholars pointing out it shares just as much in common with the other language groups around it. Difficult to tell.

Is Omotic Afroasiatic? A Critical Discussion.

The conclusion is..

My conclusion is that Omotic should be treated as an independent language family. No convincing alternative has ever been presented. Hayward (1995: 11) writes that «[i]t is, of course, a relief not to have Omotic as an isolate; we do not need a whole family of ‘Basques’ on our hands!» An alternative point of view is possible. Africa is the cradle of mankind. Why are there no language isolates on a continent where humans have lived since language was invented?

Omotic livestock terminology and its implications for the history of Afroasiatic

One response to “Is Omotic Afroasiatic? And other links.

  1. Why are there no language isolates on a continent where humans have lived since language was invented?

    Certainly. There have been important demic expansions in Africa since Neolithic but it’s odd that there are no pockets of isolated language families. Even Pygmies speak their neighbours’ languages.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s